Which Home Security System Is Right For You Quiz
Table of Contents
- Do you rent or own your home?
- What matters most to your security setup?
- Do you want professional monitoring (someone calls 911 if your alarm triggers)?
- How tech-savvy are you? How do you feel about DIY installation?
- What's your total budget for home security (hardware + first year)?
- 🔔 Best Match: Ring Alarm + Ring Cameras
- 🛡️ Best Match: SimpliSafe
- 📷 Best Match: Arlo Cameras (Self-Monitored)
- 🚪 Best Match: Video Doorbell + Smart Lock
- 🏢 Best Match: ADT Professional Security
- Frequently Asked Questions
Home security isn't one-size-fits-all — a renter in an apartment needs something completely different from a homeowner with a 3-car garage and a big yard. Answer 5 questions and we'll tell you exactly what to buy and why.
Ring is the most popular DIY home security ecosystem in America — and for good reason. Easy self-installation, optional professional monitoring with no long-term contracts ($20/month), and seamless integration between cameras and alarm sensors. It's the right choice for most homeowners who want complete coverage without complexity.
The Ring Alarm 8-Piece Kit ($199) includes a base station, keypad, 3 contact sensors, 1 motion detector, and a range extender. Add Ring Protect Plus ($20/month) for professional monitoring. No contract — cancel anytime. Expand with individual sensors ($20–$35 each) as needed.
Do you rent or own your home?
What matters most to your security setup?
Do you want professional monitoring (someone calls 911 if your alarm triggers)?
How tech-savvy are you? How do you feel about DIY installation?
What's your total budget for home security (hardware + first year)?
🔔 Best Match: Ring Alarm + Ring Cameras
Start Here: Ring Alarm 8-Piece Kit
Shop Ring Alarm Kits →Add Outdoor Coverage: Ring Stick Up Cam or Floodlight Cam
The Ring Stick Up Cam ($99) works wired or battery-powered — true flexibility for renters and owners. The Ring Floodlight Cam Wired Pro ($249) adds 2,000-lumen lights and the best detection in the lineup. Both integrate directly into your Ring app alongside your alarm sensors.
Shop Ring Cameras →🛡️ Best Match: SimpliSafe
SimpliSafe is the best professionally-monitored DIY security system — no contracts, 24/7 Fast Protect monitoring ($29.99/month), and genuinely simple installation. It's designed for people who want real professional monitoring without signing a 2–3 year ADT contract or paying $80/month.
Best Starter Kit: SimpliSafe 8-Piece Essentials
The 8-piece kit ($249) covers a standard home entry points — base station, keypad, 4 door/window sensors, a motion sensor, and a smoke detector. Add the Fast Protect plan for verified video monitoring (police dispatch only on confirmed events, not every false alarm). No annual contract required.
Shop SimpliSafe Kits →SimpliSafe vs ADT: The Real Difference
ADT requires a 36-month contract (~$45–$60/month = $1,600+ commitment). SimpliSafe is month-to-month at $29.99. ADT's professional installation ensures everything is set up correctly; SimpliSafe's DIY install takes 30–60 minutes with no tools. For most homeowners, SimpliSafe is the smarter financial choice.
Shop SimpliSafe Add-On Sensors →📷 Best Match: Arlo Cameras (Self-Monitored)
For renters or anyone who wants camera coverage without an alarm system, Arlo is the best camera-first security solution. No drilling required for battery models, best-in-class video quality, and the free Arlo app lets you self-monitor from anywhere. No monthly fee required for basic use.
Best Pick: Arlo Pro 4 (2-Camera Kit)
The Arlo Pro 4 ($249 for 2-pack) delivers 2K HDR video, color night vision, a built-in spotlight, and wire-free setup. No hub required — connects directly to WiFi. Battery lasts 3–6 months between charges. The built-in siren (80 dB) doubles as a deterrent. Free 30-day cloud storage included.
Shop Arlo Pro 4 →Arlo Secure Plan: Worth It?
The free plan covers 30 days of cloud storage for up to 5 cameras — sufficient for most renters. Arlo Secure ($12.99/month) adds 60-day storage, package detection, people/vehicle/animal AI sorting, and optional professional monitoring ($17.99/month). For renters: start with the free plan and upgrade if needed.
Shop All Arlo Cameras →🚪 Best Match: Video Doorbell + Smart Lock
If your main concern is package theft and knowing who's at your front door, a video doorbell solves 80% of the problem at 20% of the cost of a full system. Add a smart lock and you've secured the most vulnerable entry point in your home.
Best Doorbell: Ring Video Doorbell 4 or Arlo Essential Video Doorbell
The Ring Video Doorbell 4 ($219) offers pre-roll video (sees what happened before motion triggered), color night vision, and hardwired or battery operation. The Arlo Essential Video Doorbell ($149) is battery-only with 2K video and a wider field of view. Both work without a monthly subscription for basic alerts.
Shop Ring Video Doorbell 4 →Add a Smart Lock: Schlage Encode or Yale Assure
A smart lock ($150–$250) lets you lock/unlock remotely, see when doors were accessed, and give temporary codes to family or service workers. The Schlage Encode Plus is Z-Wave and Apple Home compatible. The Yale Assure SL is slimmer and works with Alexa, Google, and August. Either dramatically improves front door security.
Shop Smart Deadbolts →🏢 Best Match: ADT Professional Security
For homeowners who want professional installation, 24/7 monitored response, and the reassurance of the most recognized security brand in the country, ADT is the right choice. You'll pay more and sign a contract — but you get a fully installed, professionally monitored system on day one.
ADT Packages: What to Expect
ADT's Secure package starts around $45/month on a 36-month contract. Professional installation is included. A standard home setup includes a control panel, door/window sensors, motion detectors, and 24/7 monitoring with police/fire/medical dispatch. Add-on cameras ($10–$15/month each) are available.
Shop ADT Equipment →What ADT Gets Right That DIY Doesn't
Professional installation means sensors are placed optimally, not just conveniently. ADT technicians identify vulnerabilities you'd miss — a side door you never use, a basement window 6 feet off the ground, a fence that blocks camera sightlines. For large homes and high-security needs, professional eyes on the setup matter.
Shop Professional Security Systems →HomeGuardianTech.com participates in the Amazon Associates program and earns commissions on qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I choose the right home security system for my needs?
Start by identifying whether you rent or own your home, as renters typically need non-permanent solutions like wireless cameras and smart locks, while homeowners can invest in wired systems. Next, determine what matters most to you—whether it's video monitoring, professional alarm response, or smart home integration—then assess your comfort level with DIY installation versus professional setup. Answering these key questions will help you narrow down between popular options like Ring for renters, full alarm systems for homeowners, or hybrid solutions that combine cameras, locks, and motion sensors.
What is the best home security system for renters?
The best security system for renters uses non-invasive, wireless components that don't require permanent installation or damage to walls and doors. Ring video doorbells, wireless security cameras, and battery-powered smart locks are ideal for renters because they're portable and can move with you to your next home. Avoid wired alarm systems that require professional installation and hardwired components, as landlords typically won't permit these modifications.
Is professional monitoring worth it for a home security system?
Professional monitoring is worth it if you want the fastest emergency response and peace of mind knowing someone will call 911 if your alarm triggers while you're away or unable to respond. Without professional monitoring, you rely solely on mobile alerts and must contact emergency services yourself, which adds response time during critical situations. The monthly cost typically ranges from $15-40, making it a reasonable investment for homeowners with high-value properties or those who travel frequently.
How do I install a home security system myself?
DIY home security installation typically involves placing wireless cameras and motion sensors in strategic locations, connecting them to a hub or app, and mounting smart locks and video doorbells on doors without professional help. Most modern systems like Ring require only basic setup—downloading the app, connecting to your Wi-Fi, and positioning devices—making them ideal for those without technical expertise. If you're not tech-savvy, look for systems with clear instructions, customer support, and pre-configured packages designed for easy self-installation.
What is the most popular home security system for homeowners?
Ring is among the most popular DIY security solutions for homeowners due to its affordable video doorbells, cameras, and integration with Alexa smart home devices. For homeowners wanting professional monitoring and comprehensive coverage, traditional alarm companies like ADT or modern options like Vivint offer wired systems with 24/7 professional response. Homeowners have the flexibility to combine multiple solutions—such as Ring cameras with a separate alarm system and smart locks—to create a customized security setup.
What home security features should I prioritize?
Prioritize video monitoring (cameras and video doorbells) for visual evidence of break-ins or suspicious activity, motion sensors for detecting unauthorized entry, and smart locks for secure keyless access. If you have a large property or multiple entry points, motion-activated sensors become increasingly important, while apartment dwellers may prioritize video doorbells and smart locks. Consider professional monitoring if you're away frequently or want guaranteed emergency response, and ensure whatever system you choose integrates with your lifestyle and existing smart home tech.
How do I choose between wired and wireless home security systems?
Wired systems require professional installation, offer reliable connectivity, and integrate with professional monitoring services, making them ideal for permanent homeowners willing to invest upfront. Wireless systems are easier to install yourself, more portable for renters, and don't require drilling or permanent modifications, though they depend on battery power and Wi-Fi reliability. Choose wired if you want comprehensive coverage and professional service, or wireless if you prioritize ease of installation, flexibility, and lower upfront costs.
